We Are Hiring

Why Should All Tires Be Replaced at Once on a Mercedes 4MATIC?

Why Should All Tires Be Replaced at Once on a Mercedes 4MATIC? | Secret MBZ Garage

For Mercedes-Benz 4MATIC owners, it’s important to know that not all cars handle tire replacements the same way. While many vehicles can manage with a pair of new tires, the advanced all-wheel-drive system in a Mercedes 4MATIC requires a bit more care. Replacing all four tires at once is crucial for optimal performance and preventing potential drivetrain issues.

The Impact of Mercedes 4MATIC’s AWD System on Tire Replacement

Mercedes-Benz’s 4MATIC system is more than just an all-wheel-drive (AWD) setup. Unlike front-wheel or rear-wheel drives, 4MATIC continuously monitors each wheel’s performance, redistributing power to maintain maximum traction and stability. This sophisticated setup makes it exceptionally smooth and responsive, especially on challenging roads. However, it also means that tire inconsistencies can throw off this balance.

When all four tires wear evenly, they maintain a consistent diameter, allowing the 4MATIC system to deliver power equally to each wheel. If only one or two tires are replaced, they’ll have more tread, effectively being larger than the worn-down tires. Even a slight difference in size will mean the AWD system has to work harder to compensate, leading to stress on the drivetrain, potential mechanical issues, and poor fuel economy.

Mismatched Tires Can Damage the Differential and Drivetrain

In a 4MATIC vehicle, each tire’s speed is synchronized by a differential system, which helps manage the rotation of all wheels under varying conditions. When tires don’t match in diameter, even slightly, it can cause problems here. The differential, which is built to manage minor differences in rotation, becomes overworked trying to handle the variations introduced by mismatched tires.

Uneven tire wear can lead to:

Increased Wear on Differentials
With different-sized tires, the differential continually works to balance speed variations, which it wasn’t designed to do constantly.

Excessive Strain on the Transfer Case
The transfer case is also responsible for balancing torque between the front and rear wheels. Mismatched tires make the transfer case work overtime, increasing wear and shortening its lifespan.

The transfer case and differential are some of the most expensive parts to repair or replace in an AWD system, so saving on tire replacement now can lead to costly issues down the line.

How Does Tread Depth Affect AWD Performance

Tire tread depth is critical for maintaining equal traction across all wheels. In a Mercedes 4MATIC, when all four tires have the same tread depth, it ensures that each wheel can grip the road with the same force, distributing power evenly across all tires.

However, when only one or two tires are new, they’ll have a deeper tread and a larger circumference than the older tires. This difference makes the 4MATIC system detect a “slip” on the larger tires, leading it to redistribute power unnecessarily. This unnecessary power adjustment not only causes wear and tear on the AWD system but also affects handling, making it harder to maintain stability.

In wet or icy conditions, mismatched tires also create inconsistent traction, which can cause the vehicle to pull to one side or skid, especially if you’re braking hard or taking sharp turns. Replacing all four tires at once guarantees that your vehicle responds as it should in these conditions, helping you stay safer on the road.

Fuel Efficiency Takes a Hit with Mismatched Tires

Replacing only some of the tires on a 4MATIC vehicle can impact fuel efficiency, too. When the AWD system senses any difference in tire size, it constantly adjusts power delivery, causing the engine to work harder and consume more fuel. For many 4MATIC owners, the decision to purchase an AWD vehicle was likely influenced by the promise of solid handling and decent fuel efficiency. By replacing all four tires at once, you’re protecting both your vehicle’s longevity and your wallet at the gas pump.


Keep your Mercedes 4MATIC driving like new with the right tire maintenance. Book an appointment with Secret MBZ Garage to keep your tires—and your vehicle’s AWD system—in top shape.